Tony's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Tony's Pizza offers a tempting array of options for pizza enthusiasts. Specializing in square pizza, the menu features the well-loved Old Forge style, perfect for sharing or satisfying solo cravings. Options like the 1/2 Tray Square Pizza and Large Square Pizza, boasting 12 hearty slices, invite you to indulge in flavorful bites that transport you back to cherished moments at the lake.

For sub lovers, Tony's Meatball Sub stands out with its savory filling and satisfying taste. Gluten-friendly options also make an appearance, showcasing a Potato Crust Personal Pizza designed for those seeking a delightful alternative.

Specialty pizzas take the spotlight with options like The Works and the Bacon Cheeseburger, each carrying bold flavors and delightful textures. No meal is complete without a sweet finish, capturing nostalgic memories in every bite.

Featured Dishes

Large Square Pizza
Large Square Pizza
Tonys Pizza
Tonys Pizza
The Board Walk Pizza
The Board Walk Pizza
White Broccoli Onion Pizza
White Broccoli Onion Pizza
Tony's Pizza Menu image 1
Tony's Pizza Menu image 2
Tony's Pizza Menu image 3
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza Interior, Food, and Ambiance

Stepping into Tony's Pizza invites warmth and nostalgia, creating an environment that feels like home. The decor reflects a blend of vintage pizzazz and local charm, making it an ideal spot to unwind. You might even spot some community boards with photos and events, connecting neighbors and visitors alike.

The inviting aroma of fresh-baked pizza fills the air, enhancing the dining experience and building anticipation for the meals ahead. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for a hearty meal, the ambiance encourages connection—making it easy to share stories over a tray of pizza. This blend of delicious food and welcoming atmosphere makes Tony's a cherished spot in Peckville, creating lasting memories with every visit.

Tony's Pizza

About Tony's Pizza Food and Specialties

Tony's Pizza is a celebration of flavors and community, combining traditional recipes with a touch of heartfelt creativity. The focus on square pizza sets it apart, and each pie arrives with a delightful crust, crispy yet perfectly chewy. For those with a love for hearty flavors, the Meat Lovers and Tomato Pie offer satisfying choices that fulfill hearty appetites. Every specialty pizza is layered with the finest ingredients—fresh cheese, quality meats, and vibrant veggies combine to create mouthwatering slices that are often the centerpiece of family gatherings.

The experience doesn’t stop at pizza; the Meatball Sub garners praise for its hearty portion and rich, savory sauce, reflecting a commitment to quality.

The ability to enjoy gluten-friendly options ensures everyone finds a treat, making this pizzeria a true community favorite. Whether it is a casual meal or a celebration, Tony's menu caters to every taste and occasion.

Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza is committed to excellence in every aspect of its business. From the quality of ingredients to customer service, there is a clear dedication to providing an outstanding dining experience. The restaurant specializes in offering a range of pizzas and subs that cater to the tastes of the local community, especially celebrating the iconic Old Forge style.

The vision of Tony's Pizza extends beyond just serving food. It aims to create a sense of community, a place where people come together to enjoy good meals and create lasting memories. This commitment to quality and community ensures that every visit is special, fostering a welcoming environment that locals cherish.