Tony's Pizza

Discover Tony's Pizza in Peckville, PA, where authentic Old Forge-style pizza, savory meatball subs, and nostalgic flavors create memorable dining experiences. Call +1 570-383-3499 today!

Welcome to Tony's Pizza

Experience the finest dining

Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza welcomes everyone to a beloved local gem located at 1137 Main St, Peckville, PA 18452. This pizza restaurant captures the essence of comfort food. Known for its stunning Old Forge style pizza, Tony's brings both flavor and nostalgia to every meal. The warmth of family connections and memories fills the air, making it a perfect spot to gather with friends and family. Whether it's a casual dinner or a special occasion, each visit here promises delicious flavors, including the popular meatball subs and sweet square pies. As the aroma of freshly baked pizza rises, you'll understand why this spot has a special place in the hearts of many in the valley.

Tony's Pizza offers an array of features that keep locals coming back. First, the menu boasts a wide variety of pizzas, including specialty options like the Meat Lovers and Old Forge Classic. Not to mention, there's a delicious Potato Crust Personal Pizza for gluten-friendly diners. The 1/2 tray square pizzas provide the perfect serving size for gatherings.

Dining options suit everyone, whether you prefer a quick grab-and-go or a relaxed meal in-house.

Peak hours reveal a vibrant atmosphere, especially on busy Fridays; however, visiting during off-peak hours provides a more tranquil dining experience. With the average meal priced reasonably under $25, Tony's Pizza remains an affordable choice for quality food. Additionally, the restaurant's commitment to community shows in its friendly, welcoming staff.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

1137 Main St, Peckville, PA 18452, United States

Phone

+1 570-383-3499

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza holds a treasured spot within Peckville's culinary scene. This popular pizzeria has become synonymous with both quality ingredients and local tradition. Established to pay homage to classic pizza styles, Tony's focuses on providing authentic Old Forge recipes, creating square pies that are deeply ingrained in local history. Each pizza is crafted with care, featuring a unique blend of flavors that pay tribute to the culinary roots of the area.

Among its specials, the signature meatball sub has earned rave reviews, often cited as a must-try by patrons.

The restaurant prides itself on using fresh ingredients, ensuring every bite bursts with flavor. The regular clientele appreciates not only the food but the sense of belonging it instills. Friendly service complements the atmosphere, making you feel right at home whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular.

Tony's Pizza also stands out for its commitment to gluten-friendly options, showcasing its dedication to accommodating diverse dietary needs. The balance between tradition and innovation is key, appealing to a wide range of tastes.

Families, friends, and pizza lovers gather here to share moments, making lasting memories over a tray of deliciousness. It truly embodies the spirit of the local community, providing more than just a meal but a place to connect and enjoy life together.” ]},{

Tony's Pizza

The exterior of Tony's Pizza is welcoming and approachable. Situated on Main Street, the restaurant features a classic storefront that draws in both locals and visitors. The outdoor seating area, when available, provides a lively atmosphere perfect for enjoying the weather while indulging in hearty pizza. The vibe is always warm and friendly, echoing the welcoming charm of Peckville itself. Whether you're ordering takeout or dining in, the ambiance ensures a comfortable experience that fits any gathering.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • Sunday4-10 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday4-10 PM
  • Wednesday4-10 PM
  • Thursday4-10 PM
  • Friday2-11 PM
  • Saturday4-10 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

One of my favorite pizza places in the valley! My dad and I can easily crush a large square tray in one seating. Limited indoor space so we do takeaway, but also nice little seating area outside for the warmer weather days :). Pepperoni with extra sauce (it is delicious and sweet and unique) is the best!

N
NC

Edit: Since the owners responded to my review, I bumped the overall review up to 5-stars. Keeping a good relationship with your customers is key for a business. Let me preface by saying the owners and the people working there have great personalities and are very welcoming. I've tried a couple pizzas there and it's hit and miss. My first time I ordered there (through DoorDash) I got the Boardwalk, hoping it would be similar to boardwalk pizza down by the shore where I grew up. I got their sauce on it only to find out their sauce is way sweet, so it made the pizza overly sweet with me. The crust was great though. Then I tried the New Yorker without the extra sauce and still, too sweet. I talked with the owner there and said to try the Old Forge Classic. I recently tried the Old Forge Classic and while this one was better, it still wasn't the savory flavor I was looking for. The crust on each pizza was still perfect, but the sauce was just too overpowering for me.

D
Dustin W.

This little FAMILY OWNED, old school pizza (and other things) restaurant is awesome. The family is really nice. Love looking at the old black/white photos on the walls and The pizza? Forget it...KILLER. If you're doing something since 1948, I think it is, you're doing it very very well. Consistency is key. PS: The pizza is also awesome cold. Yes, I said cold.

A
Anthony S.

The best sweet sauce!! Love all the pizza there. The new old forge style is amazing. A must try . We love it !!

R
Renee K.

Best pizza in the area I have been eating here since I was 3 years old I love the food the people and place

V
Vincent S.

We showed up with just a few minutes left on our 2 large trays. The staff were very friendly and made small talk with us as they brought our glorious pizza out of the oven and drizzled a generous amount of their signature sauce on top. Pizza was awesome, 100000/10 will be back soon!

s
shamus248